Bonuses, commissions, incentive pay, and other forms of earned compensation often look straightforward right up until the money does not arrive. Then the real questions start: Was the payment truly “earned”? Did the plan give the employer discretion? Did the company change the rules midstream? Did termination timing affect payout? And what records actually prove the claim?
Those questions matter because compensation disputes are rarely won by outrage alone. They usually turn on documents, timing, definitions, payroll practices, and state-specific wage laws. Federal law can also matter. The U.S. Department of Labor notes that some bonuses and commissions count toward the regular rate for overtime calculations, and employers generally have recordkeeping obligations around hours and wages paid. U.S. Department of Labor on bonuses under the FLSA, U.S. Department of Labor on commissions and records
In this post, you’ll learn seven common mistakes that can quietly weaken a compensation claim, plus a practical way to think about evidence, timing, and attorney fit. If you want a broader overview before diving in, it may help to start with our guide on how bonus and commission disputes usually work in the workplace.
<aside> 💡 Scroll to the bottom for every post in this series.
</aside>
A lot of employees initially frame a bonus or commission dispute as a clerical issue: “Payroll missed it.” Sometimes that is true. But many disputes are really about contract language, incentive-plan interpretation, wage-payment statutes, and documentary proof.
That distinction matters. A payroll correction conversation often focuses on one pay period. A legal compensation dispute may involve: