Getting an unfavorable disability decision after a hearing can feel crushing. For many people, the hearing was the stage where they expected someone to finally understand the medical record, the work history, and the day-to-day limits that shaped the claim. When the Administrative Law Judge, or ALJ, says no anyway, the next question is often simple and urgent: what now?
One possible next step is asking the Social Security Appeals Council to review that decision. This is not a brand-new disability application, and it is not a new hearing right away. It is a legal review of what happened at the hearing level and whether the ALJ’s decision contains the kinds of problems that justify further action under Social Security’s rules. The Social Security Administration explains that a request for Appeals Council review generally has to be filed within 60 days after receiving the hearing decision, and SSA usually presumes the notice was received 5 days after mailing unless there is proof it arrived later (SSA request review page, SSA appeals process).
In this post you’ll learn how to ask the Appeals Council for review, what grounds often matter, what evidence may help, what happens next, and where many disability appeals lose momentum. If you want a broader overview of this stage before diving into the practical steps, it may help to start with this overview of how the review process works after an ALJ denial.
<aside> 💡 Scroll to the bottom for every post in this series.
</aside>
Timing is one of the first issues people run into after an ALJ denial. SSA states that a claimant generally has 60 days from receipt of the hearing decision to request Appeals Council review, and SSA generally presumes receipt 5 days after the date on the notice unless there is a reasonable showing otherwise (SSA appeals process, 20 C.F.R. § 422.210).
In practical terms, many people talk about this as a “65-day” window because of that 5-day mailing presumption. Still, the safer way to think about it is this:
SSA also explains that a late filing may still be considered if the claimant gives a good reason and asks for an extension of time (SSA appeals process).
A disability attorney or representative often focuses on the deadline first because a missed filing date can complicate everything else. Even when an extension request is possible, it tends to be easier to argue legal error than to first argue about lateness.
SSA allows claimants to ask for Appeals Council review in more than one way. According to SSA, a claimant can submit the request online, or complete and fax or mail Form HA-520, Request for Review of Hearing Decision/Order (SSA request review page, SSA appeals process).
At a basic level, the filing package often includes: