If you or someone you love is facing an intoxication manslaughter charge in Houston or elsewhere in Harris County, one of the most important issues may be causation. In Texas, the State does not prove this charge just by showing a driver had been drinking or using drugs and a death happened afterward. The prosecutor must prove that the defendant, by reason of intoxication, caused the death by accident or mistake under Texas Penal Code § 49.08. When the other driver also made a dangerous decision—speeding, turning illegally, running a light, drifting lanes, stopping in a live lane, or driving without lights—that causation issue can become the center of the defense. In this post, I’ll explain how I look at shared-fault fatality cases in Harris County, how Texas causation law works, and where the State’s proof can be challenged. For a broader overview of this charge, start with my guide to the basics of a Houston intoxication manslaughter case.
<aside> 💡 Scroll to the bottom for every post in this series.
</aside>
Under Texas Penal Code § 49.08, the State must prove that the accused:
That third element matters. A fatal crash alone does not automatically satisfy it. Neither does a blood test result by itself. Texas courts have repeatedly recognized that intoxication offenses like intoxication assault and intoxication manslaughter require proof that the intoxicated driving caused the result, not merely that the person was intoxicated and involved in a crash. In Hanna v. State, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals made that point plainly: proof of intoxication is not equivalent to proof of causation, and the State must prove that intoxicated driving caused the harm. Hanna v. State; Texas Penal Code § 49.08.
That is why causation fights are often so important in Harris County felony courts. These cases may be investigated by the Houston Police Department, the Harris County Sheriff’s Office, or another local agency, then prosecuted through the Harris County District Attorney’s Office at the Harris County Criminal Justice Center. The State will usually build the case around crash reconstruction, toxicology, officer observations, scene evidence, witness statements, event-data-recorder downloads, and medical examiner findings. A defense lawyer’s job is to test each link in that chain.
Texas uses a specific criminal causation rule in Texas Penal Code § 6.04(a). A person is criminally responsible if the result would not have occurred but for that person’s conduct, acting alone or together with another cause, unless the concurrent cause was clearly sufficient to produce the result and the defendant’s conduct was clearly insufficient.
That statute is the heart of many shared-fault cases.
In plain English, the prosecutor does not have to prove the accused was the only cause of the death. Texas law allows criminal responsibility when multiple causes operate together. But the State still must prove the defendant’s intoxicated driving was a real legal cause of the death under Texas Penal Code § 6.04 and § 49.08.
That creates two major defense themes:
If the deceased driver or another motorist committed a serious traffic violation, that fact matters. A sudden illegal U-turn, wrong-way travel, failure to yield, street racing, excessive speed, or a disabled vehicle left in a traffic lane can be relevant because it may be a concurrent cause under Texas Penal Code § 6.04.
Even if the accused made a mistake, the prosecutor must show that the mistake happened by reason of intoxication. That is often where the real fight is. Was the crash caused by delayed reaction time, poor judgment, lane deviation, or misperception linked to intoxication? Or would the same crash have happened even with a sober driver because the other driver’s actions created an unavoidable emergency?
That distinction can decide a case.