How to Review Coverage Positions, Defense Appointments, and Potential Conflicts After a Reservation of Rights

A reservation of rights letter can feel deceptively reassuring. The insurer is defending the case, so the immediate crisis appears contained. But that same letter often signals a second dispute developing in the background: what the insurer is defending, what it may later refuse to cover, who controls the defense, and whether the lawyer appointed by the carrier can navigate those issues without a conflict.

If you are sorting through these questions, it may help to start with a broader overview of how conditional defense and conflict issues usually arise. In this post, you’ll learn how to review an insurer’s coverage positions, evaluate defense appointments, and spot conflict issues that often become more important as the underlying case moves forward.

<aside> 💡 Scroll to the bottom for every post in this series.

</aside>

Why This Review Matters Early

In general terms, a reservation of rights means the insurer is offering a defense while preserving arguments that some or all claims may not be covered later. Courts and commentators often describe this as a common feature of liability insurance disputes, especially where facts in the underlying suit may overlap with coverage questions. The American Bar Association notes that when there is factual or legal uncertainty about whether claims could lead to covered liability, insurers frequently defend under a reservation while seeking to preserve coverage defenses and, in some cases, pursue declaratory relief later (ABA).

That timing matters. The defense being provided today can shape the factual record that affects coverage tomorrow. The ABA has also observed that in reservation-of-rights situations, conflict concerns may arise when the facts to be litigated in the liability case overlap with facts that could determine coverage (ABA).

Here’s what that often means in practice:

• The insurer may be paying for a defense, but not necessarily agreeing to indemnify every claim
• The appointed lawyer may be navigating a “tripartite” relationship involving insurer, insured, and defense counsel
• In some jurisdictions, a real conflict can give rise to a right to independent counsel paid by the insurer
• Reporting, settlement, and litigation strategy can become more sensitive than they first appear

Step 1: Identify Exactly What The Insurer Reserved

Not every reservation of rights letter is equal. Some letters are broad and generic. Others identify very specific exclusions, endorsements, conditions, or late-notice arguments.

A useful starting point is to isolate each individual coverage position. For example, the carrier may reserve rights based on:

• Intentional acts
• Professional services exclusions
• Employment-related exclusions
• Prior knowledge or prior acts
• Late notice