If you are under investigation for murder or another violent offense in Houston, Harris County, or anywhere in Greater Houston, Texas, there is a good chance your phone records are part of the case. Prosecutors and police often treat cell-site location data like a digital map of where a person was and when. But that evidence is not magic, and it is not always as precise as investigators make it sound. As a former Galveston County prosecutor who now defends people accused of serious crimes, I can tell you this: phone-location evidence can be powerful, but it can also be misunderstood, overstated, and challenged. In this post, I’ll explain what cell-site location data is, how Houston homicide investigators use it, and how the defense attacks weak or misleading phone evidence in Texas court.
<aside> 💡 Scroll to the bottom for every post in this series.
</aside>
Cell-site location data, often called CSLI, is information generated when a cell phone connects to a carrier’s network. A phone may connect to a nearby cell tower when making or receiving calls, sending texts, or using data. Those network records can later show which tower handled the connection and sometimes which sector of the tower was used.
That matters in homicide cases because Texas investigators may argue that the phone was near a crime scene, near a witness, or traveling along a route tied to the State’s theory of the case. But “near” is the key word. In many cases, cell-tower evidence does not place a person at an exact address. It usually shows that a device connected through a tower or sector that may cover a broad area, especially in dense urban parts of Houston or in less densely developed parts of Brazoria or Fort Bend County.
Texas law now specifically requires a warrant for certain location information held in electronic storage. Under Texas Code of Criminal Procedure art. 18B.322, a warrant is required to obtain covered location information from a provider, and the application must be supported by the sworn affidavit required by art. 18.01(b). Texas also separately regulates searches of the contents of a phone itself under art. 18.0215. Those are two different issues: location records from the carrier and the contents of the device in police hands. If you want a broader look at the kinds of proof that often make or break these prosecutions, read my post on the evidence problems that often decide Harris County murder cases.
When homicide investigators from the Houston Police Department, the Harris County Sheriff’s Office, or another local agency talk about “phone records,” they may mean several different things:
These are records created in the past and kept by the provider. Investigators use them to argue where a phone was over hours, days, or weeks.
These may show incoming and outgoing calls, dates, times, durations, and the phone numbers involved. In a murder case under Texas Penal Code § 19.02, prosecutors often use call patterns to suggest planning, coordination, or contact before and after a killing.
Even if the content of a message is unavailable, associated records may show activity at key times.
In some investigations, officers may try to obtain location information going forward, not just backward. Texas has detailed statutes governing warrants and related procedures for certain electronic records and location information, including Chapter 18B of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure.
Photos, app data, messages, search history, notes, and other stored information are different from carrier records. In Texas, police generally need a warrant to search a person’s cell phone after arrest under Code of Criminal Procedure art. 18.0215.
That distinction matters because I often see the State blur the lines. A detective may have lawful access to one category of information but not another. A strong defense starts by identifying exactly what was obtained, from whom, when, and under what legal authority.