If you are dealing with a criminal case in Houston, Harris County, or anywhere in Greater Houston, Texas, you may already know something went wrong with your lawyer. But not every mistake, missed call, or bad result counts as ineffective assistance of counsel under Texas law. That is an appeal and post-conviction issue with a very specific legal standard. In this post, I’ll explain what ineffective assistance of counsel means in Texas, how courts decide these claims, when a bad lawyer becomes an appeal issue, and what people in Harris County, Galveston County, Fort Bend County, and Brazoria County should do next.
Under Texas law, a person accused of a crime has the right to counsel in a criminal case. Texas Code of Criminal Procedure art. 1.051 protects that right, and art. 26.04 governs appointed counsel for indigent defendants. But the law does not guarantee a perfect lawyer. It guarantees reasonably effective assistance. That difference matters. If you are still trying to decide whether your lawyer is merely a poor fit or whether the problem may rise to an appeal issue, you may also want to read my post on the warning signs that it may be time to replace defense counsel.
<aside> 💡 Scroll to the bottom for every post in this series.
</aside>
In plain English, ineffective assistance of counsel means your lawyer’s performance fell below the legal standard required in a criminal case and that failure likely affected the outcome.
Texas courts apply the two-part test from Strickland v. Washington, and the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals has repeatedly followed that standard. Texas appellate courts also emphasize that the record must usually show both deficient performance and prejudice. In Thompson v. State, the Court of Criminal Appeals explained that the record on direct appeal is often not developed enough to prove why counsel acted the way counsel did, which is one reason many ineffective-assistance claims are difficult to win on direct appeal. See Thompson v. State; see also Rylander v. State.
That means a Texas court generally asks:
If the answer to either question is no, the claim usually fails. Texas courts also start with a strong presumption that a lawyer’s conduct might have been part of legitimate trial strategy. That presumption is a major hurdle in Harris County and everywhere else in Texas. Jackson v. State.
This is where many people get understandably frustrated.
A lawyer can be hard to reach, disorganized, late returning calls, or poor at explaining things. That may be a serious problem. It may even justify changing lawyers before trial. But appellate courts do not reverse convictions just because a lawyer was unpleasant, sloppy, or disappointing.
The issue is whether the lawyer’s conduct was so deficient that it denied the accused a fair proceeding. Texas courts do not judge that question with hindsight or by asking whether another lawyer might have done better. They ask whether the conduct was outside the wide range of professionally competent assistance and whether it mattered to the outcome. Thompson v. State.
As a former prosecutor, I can tell you this: a bad result by itself does not prove ineffective assistance. Sometimes the facts are ugly, the witnesses are credible, the video is damaging, or the lab evidence is strong. In those cases, even a solid defense may not produce the outcome the client wanted. On the other hand, when defense counsel fails to investigate, misses critical deadlines, gives plainly wrong advice about a plea, or fails to use available evidence, that can become a real appellate issue.
The first question is whether counsel’s work fell below an objective standard of reasonableness.
Examples that may support this part of the claim, depending on the facts, include: