If you were convicted in Houston, Harris County, or anywhere in Greater Houston, Texas, a criminal appeal is not a new trial and it is not a chance to start over with new evidence. It is a review by a higher court of what happened in the trial court to decide whether a legal error affected the outcome. In the Houston area, most direct criminal appeals from Harris County, Galveston County, Fort Bend County, and Brazoria County go to either the First Court of Appeals or the Fourteenth Court of Appeals, depending on the case. Under Texas Code of Criminal Procedure art. 44.02, a defendant has a right to appeal under the applicable rules. In this post, I’ll explain what a Texas criminal appeal is, what the Houston courts of appeals actually review, what they do not review, and why deadlines and error preservation matter so much.
If you want a broader roadmap of timing and procedure, I also break down the basic appeal process and Houston deadlines here.
<aside> 💡 Scroll to the bottom for every post in this series.
</aside>
A criminal appeal is a formal request for an appellate court to review the record from the trial court for legal error. In Texas, that usually means the court of appeals looks at the clerk’s record, the reporter’s record, the written motions, the exhibits, the rulings, the jury charge, and the briefs filed by both sides. The appellate court does not hear live witnesses again and does not decide whether it personally believes you are innocent. Its job is to decide whether the trial court committed a reversible legal error under the law and the record. See Texas Rule of Appellate Procedure 44.2.
That distinction matters. People often call my office after a conviction in Harris County and say, “I want to appeal because the jury got it wrong.” Sometimes there may be a valid appellate issue behind that feeling. But the question on appeal is usually not, “Was the jury unfair?” The question is, “Did the trial court make a legal mistake that the appellate court can correct based on the record?” That is a much narrower inquiry.
For most non-death-penalty criminal cases from district and county courts in this region, the appeal goes to one of Houston’s two intermediate appellate courts: the First Court of Appeals or the Fourteenth Court of Appeals. Both courts have criminal appellate jurisdiction over cases from ten counties, including Harris, Galveston, Fort Bend, and Brazoria Counties. Death-penalty cases do not go to these courts in the ordinary way, and post-conviction felony habeas matters are handled differently. The Texas Judiciary’s overview of the courts of appeals confirms that the First through Fourteenth Courts of Appeals are Texas’s intermediate appellate courts, and both Houston courts’ own websites state that they handle criminal appeals from their covered counties, except where the death penalty has been imposed.
In practical terms, if your case was tried at the Harris County Criminal Justice Center, or in a Harris County criminal district court, county criminal court at law, Galveston County district court, or similar trial court in this region, your direct appeal will usually be assigned to one of those two Houston courts.
The First and Fourteenth Courts of Appeals review claimed legal errors that appear in the appellate record. Common issues include: