If you are being investigated in Houston, Harris County, or anywhere in Greater Houston, one of the most misunderstood parts of Texas criminal law is when Miranda rights actually apply. Many people believe police must read Miranda warnings before every question. That is not how it works. In Texas, Miranda and Texas Code of Criminal Procedure article 38.22 usually matter only when law enforcement is conducting a custodial interrogation. In this post, I will explain what that means, why it matters in Harris County cases, and what you should do if Houston police, the Harris County Sheriff’s Office, or another agency wants to question you.
<aside> 💡 Scroll to the bottom for every post in this series.
</aside>
A custodial interrogation has two parts:
Both must be present before Miranda-style warnings are generally required for the State to use the statement in its case-in-chief. Texas courts treat “custody” under article 38.22 consistently with Miranda custody: the question is whether, under the objective circumstances, a reasonable person would feel their freedom was restrained to the degree associated with a formal arrest. Texas appellate courts repeatedly apply that objective test in article 38.22 cases. See, for example, Dowthitt v. State and more recent Texas appellate decisions following the same rule. Article 38.22 governs when statements may be used against an accused in a Texas criminal case.
“Interrogation” is broader than direct questioning. It can include words or actions by police that they should know are reasonably likely to produce an incriminating response. Texas courts recognize that point when deciding whether an interview crossed the line into custodial interrogation. Article 38.22 applies only to statements that result from custodial interrogation, and section 5 of that article preserves the admissibility of statements that do not stem from custodial interrogation.
Under article 38.22, section 2, before a written statement from a custodial interrogation can be used, the accused must be warned that:
That last protection is especially important in Texas practice. If police are questioning you, you do not have to keep talking.
For oral statements, article 38.22, section 3 adds recording requirements. In many Texas felony cases, whether a statement was recorded, how the warnings were given, and whether there was a valid waiver become major suppression issues.
Also remember this: if you have been arrested, a magistrate must give important warnings under article 15.17 of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure, including the right to counsel and the right to remain silent. But an article 15.17 warning after arrest is not the same as police having free rein to question you however they want. The State still has to satisfy the rules that govern statements.